The Best Pizza Pot Pie (The Ultimate Comfort Food Fusion)
5.0 (23 reviews)
Jump to recipe
Pizza pot pie inverted on plate with golden pizza dough crust on top, melted mozzarella, marinara, pepperoni, and Italian sausage filling cascading out
Dinner

The Best Pizza Pot Pie (The Ultimate Comfort Food Fusion)

5.0 (23 reviews)
· 45 min
Save
Published May 6, 2026
Category Dinner
By Sara

Introduction

Tutorial: how to make pizza pot pie — Pizzeria Uno copycat. Layered ramekins, dough on top, invert at serving. 50 min.

Ingredients List

  • 1/2 lb Italian sausage + 20 pepperoni + 4 oz mushrooms + 1/2 onion + 3 garlic + 1.5 cups marinara + 2 cups mozzarella + 1/2 cup parm + spices
  • 1 lb pizza dough (4 portions) + olive oil + flour + 1 egg + parm + Italian + flaky salt
  • Basil + parsley + chili flakes + parm + olives

Timing

Close-up of pizza pot pie cross-section showing layers of pizza dough, melted cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and rich tomato sauce

Filling 15. Roll/assemble 10. Bake 20. Rest 5. Total 50 min.

Step 1 — Brown Sausage

6 min crumbled. Drain. Onion 3 min, garlic/mushrooms 4 min, marinara + spices 3 min.

Step 2 — Ramekins

425°F. 4 deep ramekins (12-16 oz) oiled.

Step 3 — Layer Inverted

Pepperoni bottom (top after flip). Mozz + parm. Filling. Mozz again.

Step 4 — Dough Caps

4 circles 1 inch larger. Press to seal edges.

Step 5 — Egg Wash + Bake

Egg + parm + Italian + salt + slit. 20 min deep golden.

Step 6 — Rest + Invert

5 min. Knife edge. Plate on top, flip. Towel hot. Garnish.

Nutritional Information

  • Calories 720 | Protein 34g | Fat 40g | Carbs 54g | Calcium 40% DV

Healthier Alternatives

Turkey sausage/pepperoni. Part-skim mozz. Spinach. Whole wheat dough.

Serving Suggestions

Caesar salad. Garlic bread. Chianti. Antipasti, tiramisu.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Overfilled
  • Loose seal
  • No slit
  • Early invert
  • No rest

Storing Tips

Best fresh. 3 days fridge. 350°F 12 min. No freeze. Filling 3 days.

Conclusion

That’s how to make pizza pot pie. Comment your topping combo, share a photo, subscribe.

FAQs

Dough source? Trader Joe’s, pizzeria.

Big or individual? 2-qt 30-35 min.

Sausage sub? Beef + fennel.

Make ahead? Filling 3 days.

Vegetarian? Roasted veg.

Soggy bottom? Drain wet filling.

Recipe Card: Pizza Pot Pie

Prep: 25 min | Bake: 20 min | Rest: 5 min | Total: 50 min | Serves: 4 | Calories: 720/serving

Ingredients

  • 1/2 lb Italian sausage + 20 pepperoni + 4 oz mushrooms + 1/2 onion + 3 garlic + 1.5 cups marinara + 2 cups mozzarella + 1/2 cup parm + spices
  • 1 lb pizza dough divided into 4 + olive oil + flour + 1 beaten egg + parm + Italian + flaky salt
  • Fresh basil + parsley + chili flakes + extra parm

Instructions

  1. Brown sausage 6 min; drain; cook onion 3 min, garlic/mushrooms 4 min; add marinara + spices 3 min.
  2. Layer ramekins inverted: pepperoni bottom, mozzarella + parm, meat sauce, more mozzarella.
  3. Roll 4 dough circles 1 inch wider than ramekins; seal firmly over filling.
  4. Egg wash + parm + Italian + salt; small slit; bake at 425°F for 20 min.
  5. Rest 5 min; loosen edges with knife.
  6. Place plate over ramekin and invert; lift hot ramekin off; garnish.

Nutrition (per serving)

Calories 720 | Protein 34g | Fat 40g | Carbs 54g | Calcium 40% DV

Pizza pot pie inverted on plate with golden pizza dough crust on top, melted mozzarella, marinara, pepperoni, and Italian sausage filling cascading out
The Best Pizza Pot Pie (The Ultimate Comfort Food Fusion)

You might also like